Arborist explains why good recommendations need clear explanations to clients

by The Pro Arb Team | Oct 30, 2026 | Long reads, Training and careers, Trees and woodland

Tyler Kaulbars, founder of Arborist Art

A board member can read three tree-work quotations and still not know what they are being asked to approve. One says “prune”, another says “reduce”, and a third recommends removal. The prices are easy to compare. The reasons may not be.

As an arborist and business owner in Florida, I work in a market where homeowners’ associations and property managers make decisions for shared landscapes. The setting may differ from a residential development in the UK, but the question is familiar: how do we help someone make a responsible decision about work they are not trained to evaluate?

A technically sound recommendation matters. So does explaining it well enough that the client can understand the objective, consider the alternatives and recognise the limits.

Start with the concern, not the operation

Before explaining what you would do, ask what prompted the enquiry.

Is a branch touching a building? Is a resident worried about a tree’s movement? Is the board responding to a complaint about shade? Those concerns may lead to different conversations, even when they involve the same tree.

“What are you hoping will be different after the work?” is a useful question. So is, “Who else needs to understand this before you can decide?”

A property manager may need to explain the recommendation to a board that never attended the site visit. Give that person something clearer than a price and a technical term.

Describe the intended result

“Prune the tree” names an activity. It does not explain the result.

If the objective is clearance from a building, identify the tree, the relevant part of its crown and the clearance proposed. Explain why that amount of work is appropriate, rather than assuming that more pruning means a better result.

The International Society of Arboriculture’s guidance notes that every pruning cut can affect a tree’s growth and that heavy pruning can place significant stress on it. That is worth translating into the client’s decision: we are recommending the work needed for a particular purpose, not simply removing as much as possible.

Keep the explanation plain without making the specification vague. A photograph showing the relevant branches can help, but it should support a written description, not replace one. For UK work, Greater Cambridge’s published guidance provides a useful example of the need to identify individual trees and specify the extent of the proposed work, rather than relying on phrases such as “tidy up”.

Explain the reasonable alternatives

Clients should understand why you recommend one course of action over another.

That does not mean presenting every imaginable option or treating unsuitable work as a reasonable choice. It means explaining the alternatives that genuinely apply to the tree and the site.

Depending on the findings, those might include limited pruning, further assessment, monitoring with a defined review point, or removal. Explain what each option addresses, what it leaves unresolved and why you favour the recommendation you have made.

If waiting is reasonable, say what would be reviewed and when. If delay is not advisable, explain the reason and the recommended timing. Do not use urgency as a sales technique or offer delay merely because it is the cheapest option.

A client may still choose differently. Our role is to make the reasoning clear, not to make their questions feel unwelcome.

Be direct about limits

A recommendation should not sound more certain than the assessment behind it.

Explain what you inspected and any important limitations. If a question needs additional investigation, distinguish that from something you have already established. Avoid turning a concern raised by a resident into a confirmed finding simply by repeating it in the quotation.

Be equally clear about the limits of the proposed work. Creating clearance does not stop future growth. Removing a particular branch does not settle every question about the rest of the tree. If further inspection or maintenance is recommended, explain why.

These are not details to hide in small print. They affect what the client believes they are buying.

Make the quotations comparable

When the discussion turns to price, bring it back to the scope.

Are the quotations addressing the same trees and the same objective? Do they include the same extent of pruning, access arrangements, removal of cut material and site clean-up? If a tree is being removed, is stump work included or separate?

Explain relevant differences without guessing why another contractor priced the work differently. A lower figure alone does not establish poor work, just as a higher figure does not prove better advice.

Separate necessary work from optional items, and identify anything that must be resolved before work starts. The client should not have to discover an exclusion when the crew arrives.

Leave room for a real question

Instead of ending with “Does that make sense?”, ask, “What would you need to explain this to the rest of the board?”

That can reveal a missing photograph, an unclear alternative or a concern you have not addressed. It also gives the client permission to say they are not ready to decide.

A clear explanation is not a guarantee that we will win the work. It gives the client a fair basis for deciding. They should leave knowing what we recommend, why we recommend it, what it will cost and what it will not do. That is part of doing the job well.


Tyler Kaulbars is an ISA certified arborist and the founder of Arborist Art in Sarasota-Bradenton, Florida. He established the business in 2019 and works with homeowners’ associations and property managers on tree-care decisions.